Pros and Cons of Homemade Dog Food: Is it Better Than Industrial Dog Food?

April 21, 2023
Annette Thompson

We can find several pros and cons of homemade dog food, as It’s no secret that pet owners want the best for their furry family members.

But with so many different types available, including exclusive dog food, it can take time to decide which is healthier for your dog. This post will explore if homemade dog food is better than commercial varieties.

Here we’ll discuss the pros and cons of homemade dog food and industrial Food, so you can decide what type of diet will serve your pup best in the long run.

As any dedicated pet parent knows, finding a nutritious yet tasty meal option isn’t always easy – but it doesn’t have to be complicated, either! With some research and knowledge about the ingredients used in each Food type, you can ensure your beloved pooch gets the nutrition they need without sacrificing flavor or quality.

Please keep reading to learn more about how homemade vs. commercial foods stack up against each other regarding health benefits for our four-legged friends.

Pros and Cons of Homemade Dog Food

Here is an overview of the pros and cons of homemade Food, bellow it there is a more detailed explanation:

Pros of Homemade Dog Food Cons of Homemade Dog Food
Tailored nutrition Proable Nutritional imbalance
Ingredient transparency Time-consuming
Fresh and nutrient-rich Usually More Expensive
Variety and flavor Potential food safety risks
Bonding experience Limited convenience
  • Tailored nutrition: You can customize meals to meet your dog’s unique dietary needs, allergies, and sensitivities.
  •  Ingredient transparency: You control the ingredients, ensuring your dog receives high-quality, wholesome ingredients without additives.
  •  Fresh and nutrient-rich: New ingredients can provide a higher nutritional value than processed commercial dog food.
  •  Variety and flavor: You can offer diverse tastes and textures, keeping your dog excited and engaged during mealtime.
  •  Bonding experience: Cooking for your pet can create a deeper bond between you and your furry friend, involving them in the process.

Cons of Homemade Dog Food:

  • Nutritional imbalance: Crafting balanced meals can be challenging, leading to potential deficiencies or imbalances in essential nutrients.
  •  Time-consuming: Preparing homemade meals requires planning, shopping, and cooking, which can be time-consuming, especially for busy pet owners.
  •  Cost considerations: Homemade dog food may be more expensive due to quality ingredients and potential supplementation needs.
  •  Potential food safety risks: Improper food handling, storage, or preparation can pose risks of bacterial contamination or inadequate cooking.
  •  Limited convenience: Homemade dog food needs more-packaged portions, making it less suitable for travel or on-the-go situations.

As we weigh these pros and cons, you will gain a comprehensive understanding of the homemade dog food landscape, allowing you to make an informed decision that aligns with your dog’s specific needs and lifestyle. So, let’s uncover the truth and discover the path to a healthier, happier life for your furry friend.

Homemade Dog Food

Nutritional Content of Dog Food

When providing a healthy diet for our canine companions, homemade and commercial dog food have their benefits. Both options offer portion control and the potential for dietary balance; however, one may be better suited when considering nutritional Content.

Homemade meals give owners greater flexibility in terms of ingredients, and vets can tailor them to meet any specific needs your pet may have. The advantage of homemade Food is that you precisely know which components are being used; this allows you to ensure that your pup’s diet avoids anything they may be allergic or intolerant to. Additionally, there is no risk of contamination from added preservatives or fillers as all components of the meal are sourced directly from home cooks. However, creating balanced meals requires knowledge about proper dog nutrition, so mistakes could occur if one does not take appropriate precautions when preparing these dishes. So use recipes crafted by veterinaries and always consult them with your vet.

Commercial dog food is typically more convenient than cooking at home since most brands list the exact quantity of proteins, fats, carbohydrates, and fiber contained within each serving size on their labels. This makes it easier for owners to monitor their pet’s consumption without having to break down individual recipes themselves every time they feed them something new. Furthermore, many manufacturers use high-quality sources like natural meats rather than byproducts such as bone meal or animal fat, as well as natural flavors instead of artificial ones that may contain sugar substitutes or colorings known to cause health problems over time.

On the other hand, store-bought Food has undergone strict quality control measures to ensure its safety before reaching consumers. It is also often fortified with additional vitamins and minerals beyond what is found naturally in its ingredients.

Homemade and commercially produced meals have advantages depending on an owner’s personal preference and budget constraints – but ultimately, choosing a healthier option comes down to selecting fresh whole foods whenever possible while avoiding processed items full of unhealthy additives regardless of where they come from.

Dog Food Cost Comparison

Consider the cost comparison in the pros and cons of homemade dog food.

Regarding price, commercial dog foods are typically cheaper than homemade meals. This could make a difference in households with multiple pets or on tight budgets. Commercial foods also often have longer storage times as they’re designed for extended shelf life, whereas homemade Food needs to be cooked more regularly and only lasts for a short time once prepared.

On the other hand, there may be some upfront costs associated with buying ingredients for home-prepared meals including food containers and cookware, if you don’t have them.

Additionally, cooking at home means knowing exactly what goes into your meal – which many owners find reassuring when considering nutrition.

Overall, both homemade and commercial diets have pros and cons which should be taken into consideration before deciding on one option or the other:

  • Homemade Food offers greater control over ingredients but requires more preparation time;
  •  Commercial Food is convenient but has shorter shelf lives;
  •  Cost varies depending on the size of your pet and its specific dietary requirements;
  •  Storage considerations must also be considered when selecting either type of diet.

Choosing between homemade and commercial dog food depends primarily on individual preferences and lifestyle habits. Whatever works best for you and your pet will likely be the healthiest option!

Dog Food Ingredient Quality

As we’ve established, the costs associated with homemade versus commercial dog food vary widely. But the price is hardly the only factor to consider when determining which type of diet is best for your pet – ingredient quality is also an important consideration.

When it comes to preparing meals at home, you ultimately control what goes into them and can ensure that only high-quality ingredients are used. You know exactly where each item is sourced from and can be sure there won’t be any additives or preservatives that could harm your pup’s health. Plus, since you’re preparing the meal, you can customize it according to your pet’s needs and preferences.

On the other hand, purchasing pre-made commercial foods gives you less control over what ingredients are included in the product. While some brands may provide a list of ingredients on their packaging, this only sometimes gives an accurate picture of what’s inside; certain cheaper products may include fillers like corn syrup or wheat to pad out the nutritional value without adding much benefit. Also industrial dog food goes through process that can include higher temperatures and chemical transformations that reduces the nutrient quantity of the original ingredientes.

Home Made Dog food

Ease Of Preparation

In the pros and cons of homemade dog food, one that is evident but you should consider is that making homemade dog food is more labor-intensive than purchasing commercial dog food. It requires you to source the ingredients, measure proper portion sizes and cook or prepare each meal from scratch. This can be time-consuming, especially if your pet has specific dietary requirements that require careful attention. However, with some pre-planning and organization, having delicious meals for your pup ready in advance is possible – giving you peace of mind knowing they are eating healthy foods.

In addition to controlling portion size when preparing meals at home, another advantage of making homemade dog food is reducing the environmental impact associated with store-bought options. Packaging materials used by large companies create excess waste while buying fresh local ingredients reduces your carbon footprint significantly and it helps support local business. Although there may be an initial cost involved in acquiring specific kitchen equipment like blenders and slow cookers, these items will last a long time and help make feeding your pup easier.

When it comes down to evaluating the pros and cons of homemade dog food and commercially made dog foods, both options offer benefits and drawbacks for pet owners who want what’s best for their furry friends. Homemade meals provide complete control over portions and allow for greater flexibility when selecting ingredients that meet specific dietary needs; however, this method takes longer to prepare than simply opening up a bag of kibble from the store.

On the other hand, store-bought products come conveniently packaged, so all you have to do is scoop them into bowls which makes feeding much more straightforward – but often includes artificial preservatives that could harm pets in the long term. Ultimately, whether you decide to go with store-bought or homemade depends on your preferences and lifestyle choices since each option offers its own set of advantages and disadvantages related to health benefits, ease of preparation, and environmental impacts – all factors worth considering when deciding how best to feed your four-legged family members!

Veterinary Recommendations

When deciding between homemade or commercial dog food, ease of preparation may be a factor. However, another critical consideration is veterinary recommendations.

Most veterinarians suggest pet owners should feed their animals based on the sourcing advice given by reputable pet nutritionists. This means that pet owners should research where their ingredients come from and what nutritional value they provide for the animal. Furthermore, many vets recommend feeding guidelines for each type of pet depending on its size, age, health condition, and activity level.

Feeding dogs too much can lead to obesity, which can cause joint problems and other chronic medical illnesses. On the contrary, not giving them enough nutrients also causes long-term health issues such as growth retardation and anemia due to inadequate protein levels in the diet.

Therefore, when choosing between homemade or commercial dog food, it’s essential to ensure your beloved companion has all the necessary vitamins and minerals for good health. In addition to meeting nutritional requirements, some commercially prepared foods are fortified with added supplements like probiotics or omega fatty acids, aiding digestion and building immunity against disease.

Although these products can be expensive compared to home cooking options, they offer convenience since nutrient ratios are already pre-calculated, so you don’t have to worry about getting the balance right. Considering all aspects of canine nutrition will help ensure your pup enjoys every mealtime while growing strong and healthy into adulthood!

No matter what dietary approach you choose – homemade or commercial – being mindful of portion sizes and consulting your vet regularly is vital for maintaining optimal health for your furry friend.

Dog Eating Food

Frequently Asked Questions

Can My Dog Eat Rice and Chicken Everday?

No. While giving rice and chicken to your dog can be very tasty and nutritious, it doesn’t have the right balance of nutrients to provide them daily. You can mix it with kibble to give it to them everyday, or give them the rice and chicken every other day. Don’t forget to consult your vet whenever you make any adjustment to your pet’s diet.

What are the Pros and Cons of Homemade Dog Food?
Pros of Homemade Dog Food Cons of Homemade Dog Food
Tailored nutrition Probable Nutritional imbalance
Ingredient transparency Time-consuming
Fresh and nutrient-rich Usually More Expensive
Variety and flavor Potential food safety risks
Bonding experience Limited convenience
Is it Healthier to Give your Dog Homemade Dog Food?

Homemade Food can be way healthier than industrial dog food if the recipe is tailored to the nutrients required by your dog for its age and size, which a vet can say of this, and if the Food is handled with good hygiene practices. Otherwise, commercial Food is a safer bet.

Do Vets Recommend Homemade Dog Food?

“If it’s a homemade food diet based on the requirements of the dog, it can be healthy,” says our Vet at BVDR, Alberto


In conclusion, when deciding between homemade and commercial dog food for your pet, there is no one-size-fits-all answer. You must evaluate the potential health benefits of each option to make an informed decision that is right for your pup.

Ultimately, I suggest you consult a veterinarian or pet nutritionist before changing your pet’s diet. To keep Fido healthy and happy, consider all the factors involved when switching diets – such as storage times, nutrient balance, and special considerations – to determine which choice will be best for them!

Alliteration here helps grab attention: The only way we can ensure our four-legged friends get the nourishment they need to thrive is by carefully considering home-cooked meals and store-bought kibbles.

If you made it this far you are certainly a dog-lover and you are willing to do what it takes to take care of pooches. In Bone Voyage dog rescue we share that spirit we you, as we rescue stray dogs from the streets of Mexico in Ajijic. We give them medical care, spaying/neutering, feed them and take them abroad to their forever homes in the USA and Canada. If you wanna help us feeding all these puppies please consider making a regular donation.

Also, if you are considering adopting a dog or you know of someone that does, please browse our list of dogs for adoptionand you might find your new best friend here!

Help them have their forever home

We fly dogs to Vancouver, Montreal, Toronto, Seattle, Portland, plus any other city we have a flight angel for.