Pedigree vs. Personality: The Debate of Purebreds and Mixed Breeds

October 28, 2023
Joseph Olid
a brown dog lying on a couch

When it comes to choosing a canine companion, one of the most heated debates centers around the choice between pedigree dogs and mixed breeds.

Some people swear by the elegance and predictability of purebred dogs, while others are drawn to the quirky charm and unique personalities of mixed breeds.

It’s a decision that goes beyond just picking a furry friend; it’s a reflection of our values, expectations, and the kind of relationship we want with our four-legged friends.

In this blog post, we’ll dive deep into the pedigree vs. personality debate, exploring the merits and drawbacks of both, and hopefully helping you make an informed choice for your next canine companion.

The Allure of Purebreds

A Legacy of Tradition

The term “purebred” is often associated with elegance, tradition, and an illustrious ancestry. Purebred dogs come from well-documented lineages, often tracing back generations, with a proven track record of specific traits and characteristics.

For many, owning a purebred dog can be akin to having a living work of art. Think of the regal Dachshund, the dignified Great Dane, or the charming French Bulldog. These breeds have a rich history and are often symbols of national pride.

Predictability and Specific Traits

One significant advantage of purebred dogs is predictability. When you choose a purebred, you generally have a good idea of what to expect in terms of size, coat type, temperament, and even health.

This predictability can be especially appealing if you have specific requirements or constraints, such as living in a small apartment or needing a hypoallergenic dog.

For example, if you’re in the market for French Bulldog puppies, you’ll likely choose a purebred if you want the classic “bat-eared” look and personality that’s characteristic of the breed.

Competitive Performance

Purebred dogs often excel in specific roles and competitions. The breed’s characteristics and talents are finely tuned over time, making them ideal for activities such as dog shows, agility contests, and working roles like herding or hunting.

If you have ambitions for your dog to compete or participate in specific events, a purebred can give you a competitive edge.

The Charm of Mixed Breeds

A Blend of Personalities

Mixed breed dogs, often referred to as “mutts,” bring with them a unique charm that is born of diversity. These dogs are a delightful blend of different breeds, resulting in a wide variety of appearances and temperaments.

When you adopt a mixed breed, you’re welcoming a dog with a one-of-a-kind personality that is a product of its unique genetic makeup.

Health and Hybrid Vigor

One notable advantage of mixed breed dogs is their potential for better health. They can be less prone to some of the hereditary health issues that are common in purebreds.

This phenomenon, known as hybrid vigor, is the result of a broader gene pool. Mixed breed dogs are, in a sense, the products of genetic diversity, which can lead to increased resilience and a lower risk of genetic diseases.

Saving a Life

Another compelling reason to consider a mixed breed is the opportunity to provide a loving home for a rescue dog. Many mixed breed dogs end up in shelters, and choosing to adopt one can be a heartwarming and socially responsible decision.

It’s a chance to make a difference in a dog’s life and experience the profound bond that often forms between a rescue dog and their adoptive owner.

A Matter of Lifestyle and Preference

Your Living Space

When deciding between a purebred and a mixed breed, it’s essential to consider your living space. Some purebreds come in larger sizes and may not be suited for apartment living, while mixed breeds can offer a more adaptable size range.

Your living space should harmonize with your dog’s size, exercise requirements, and energy levels.

Health Considerations

Health considerations are crucial when choosing a dog.

On the other hand, if you’re concerned about genetic health issues, mixed breeds might be a safer bet due to their broader gene pool.

Activity Level

Your activity level and lifestyle play a significant role in this decision. Some breeds are naturally more energetic and require regular exercise.

Others are content with a more laid-back lifestyle. Matching your dog’s activity level to your own is crucial to ensure a happy and healthy relationship.

Training and Socialization

Each dog is an individual, but some breeds have specific training and socialization needs. Purebreds often come with breed-specific characteristics that need attention, such as herding tendencies or guarding instincts.

Mixed breeds may have a more diverse set of behaviors, so it’s essential to understand and address their unique needs.

Proper Care and Nutrition

All dogs, purebred or mixed, require proper care, nutrition, and regular veterinary attention. Understanding your dog’s specific needs and tailoring their care accordingly is crucial for their health and happiness. Whether it’s a Frenchton dog breed or a mutt, they rely on you to provide the best possible care.

The Final Decision

Choosing between a purebred and a mixed breed is a highly personal decision. It involves understanding your lifestyle, preferences, and priorities. Here are some factors to consider so that you can make an informed choice:

●  Consider Your Lifestyle: Match your living situation, activity level, and space with a dog that suits your circumstances.

●  Health Matters: Evaluate health concerns, including allergies and genetic predispositions, when deciding between purebred and mixed breed.

●  Embrace the Unexpected: If you’re open to surprises and unique personalities, a mixed breed might be your best friend.

●  Heritage and Tradition: If you have a deep affinity for a particular breed and appreciate its history, a purebred dog may be the right choice.

●  Responsibility is Key: Remember that responsible dog ownership is the same, regardless of breed. Commit to providing the best care, training, and love for your furry friend.


Black pug puppy

In the great debate of pedigree vs. personality, there is no one-size-fits-all answer. Both purebred and mixed breed dogs have their unique merits and drawbacks. The choice ultimately comes down to your individual preferences and lifestyle.

Whether you decide to welcome a graceful purebred like a French Bulldog into your home or opt for the charming unpredictability of a mixed breed, what matters most is the love, care, and commitment you offer your four-legged friend.

In the end, it’s not about whether your dog has a pedigree but rather the pawprints they leave on your heart.

Help them have their forever home

We fly dogs to Vancouver, Montreal, Toronto, Seattle, Portland, plus any other city we have a flight angel for.