Adopting a Craigslist Dog, Top 4 Disadvantages

April 13, 2023
Annette Thompson

This post is also available in: Français (French) Español (Spanish)

Craigslist is a popular online platform for buying, selling, and trading items and services, including Craigslist dogs.

While it may seem like a convenient way to find a new canine companion, adopting a dog through Craigslist has its own advantages and disadvantages. In this blog post, we’ll discuss the pros and cons, including ethical concerns of adopting a dog through Craigslist, to help you make an informed decision when searching for your new furry friend and consider adopting a pet from a Petco or Petsmart event.

1. Lack of Accountability and Transparency on Craigslist Dogs

Unlike shelters and rescue organizations, Craigslist Dogs has no regulations or oversight to ensure the ethical treatment of animals. This means there is a higher risk of encountering dishonest or negligent individuals who may need to provide accurate information about the dog’s health, temperament, or background.

2. Potential Health and Behavioral Issues

A Craigslist dog may not have received proper medical care, vaccinations, or behavioral training, which can lead to unexpected health or behavioral issues that may require additional time, effort, and money to address after adoption.

Craigslist Dog

3. Risk of Scams

Unfortunately, scams are not uncommon on Craigslist, and the pet adoption section is no exception. Be cautious of individuals asking for payment or personal information upfront, as well as those unwilling to let you meet the dog in person before completing the transaction and see if you can visit the place the Craigslist dog was born and their mother and father.

4. Supporting Unethical Practices

Adopting a Craigslist dog may inadvertently support unethical practices like backyard breeding or puppy mills. Adopting from a shelter or rescue organization can help combat these practices, ensure that your adoption supports responsible and ethical pet ownership, and allow an abandoned dog to get a new home.

Pros of Adopting a or Buy a Dog on Craigslist


1. Affordability

One of the main advantages of looking at Craigslist puppies for sale is the potential for lower costs. Many people list their dogs for a small rehoming fee or even for free, making it an affordable option compared to shelters or breeders that often have higher adoption fees, but does it worth it?

2. Some Craigslist dogs were rescued

You can also find free pets on Craigslist, which are genuine rescued dogs of well-intentioned citizens that saved them from the street or domestic abuse, but as it is Craigslist, you ought to be very careful you are not going through a scam.

Adopting a Dog at Petco, PetSmart, and Other Adoption Events

Adoption events at pet stores like Petco and PetSmart and other community events are popular for people to find their new furry family member. These events offer an opportunity to meet a variety of dogs in need of loving homes, all in one place. In this blog post, we will discuss the advantages and disadvantages of adopting a dog at Petco, PetSmart, and other adoption events and provide tips on preparing for a successful adoption experience.

Advantages of Adopting at Petco, PetSmart, and Other Adoption Events.

1. Variety of Dogs to Choose From

You can find a diverse selection of dogs at adoption events, including different breeds, sizes, ages, and temperaments. This variety increases your chances of finding the perfect match for your family and lifestyle.

2. Support for Local Rescue Organizations and Shelters

Local rescue organizations and shelters often organize events. By adopting a dog at one of these events, you are not only giving a loving home to a dog in need but also supporting the efforts of these organizations in saving and caring for more animals.

Craigslist Dog

3. Knowledgeable Staff and Volunteers

During adoption events, staff and volunteers from the hosting organization are usually present to provide information and guidance about the dogs available for adoption. They can help answer questions about a specific dog’s history, personality, and care requirements, making it easier for you to make an informed decision.

There are a couple of disadvantages of adopting a dog through a Petco or Petsmart Adoption Event, as it could be a crowded and noisy place which can stress out dogs and may make it difficult for you to get a true sense of a dog’s personality or to have a meaningful interaction with them. You can also feel the pressure to make the decision quickly, as other potential adopters may also be interested in the same dog. This time constraint can make it difficult to thoroughly evaluate whether a particular dog is the right fit for your family.


Getting a Craigslist dog might not be the most ethical option. Still, doing it through there, you may find a dog rescued from the street that needs a new home from a wholesome citizen but remembers to be very careful so you are not a victim of a scam or any other crime.

Suppose you are looking for a safer bet to adopt a dog. In that case, you can go to a Petco or Petsmart event, where you can meet a lot of dogs and choose one that you like, knowing beforehand that you have to decide on the spot; anyhow, you can read on everything you have to consider before adopting a dog.

You can also adopt a dog rescued from the streets in Mexico from Bone Voyage Dog Rescue, as it might be the best option for those looking for a canine companion. With a wide variety of breeds available and the promise of providing a better life for dogs in need, Bone Voyage Dog Rescue offers something that other shelters, breeders, and organizations cannot. Adopting Bone Voyage will not only give you a furry friend for life but also give a dog a second chance at the life it deserves.

The decision on where to adopt your beloved pup comes down to what works best for you. Whether you adopt from Bone Voyage Dog Rescue in Mexico or a local shelter or rescue, breeder, Craigslist ad, ASPCA, or Human Society, remember that you are saving a life. We thank you for considering adoption to bring a four-legged family member into your life, and we hope that you and your pup are blessed with years of love, companionship, and joy.

Help them have their forever home

We fly dogs to Vancouver, Montreal, Toronto, Seattle, Portland, plus any other city we have a flight angel for.