Top 7 Best Training Collars for Stubborn Dogs in 2024

Training a stubborn dog might seem like climbing a tall mountain, but the right collar can make it a breeze. These handy collars are a game-changer for dog owners, helping to manage troublesome habits like barking, jumping, or chewing on everything they find. Selecting the proper collar is crucial. Choosing the wrong one isn’t just disappointing; it might even hurt your furry friend.

When it comes to training collars for stubborn dogs, there are several types to choose from, including shock collars, vibration collars, and spray collars. Shock collars deliver a mild electric shock to the dog’s neck, while vibration collars produce a buzzing sensation. Spray collars, on the other hand, emit a burst of citronella or other unpleasant scent to deter the dog from unwanted behavior.

One critical factor to consider when choosing a training collar is the size and temperament of your dog. Some collars are designed for small dogs, while others are better suited for larger breeds. Additionally, some collars may be too harsh for sensitive dogs, while others may not be strong enough for highly stubborn dogs.

We spent hours researching and testing various training collars to identify the best options for stubborn dogs. In the following sections, we’ll share our top picks and what makes them stand out.

Best Training Collars for Stubborn Dogs

When it comes to training stubborn dogs, a regular collar may not always do the trick. That’s where training collars come in handy. With various types and features available, it can be overwhelming to choose the right one for your furry friend. That’s why we’ve compiled a list of the best training collars for stubborn dogs. Our team has researched and tested these products to ensure that they are effective, safe, and reliable. Read on to find the perfect training collar for your pup.

1. SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer 425XS

We highly recommend the SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer 425XS for anyone looking for a training collar for their stubborn dog. This e-collar is designed for high-drive, more stubborn dogs and offers a higher static stimulation range than the 425X. With up to 500 yards of range, this collar can support training up to 3 dogs with the same remote with purchase of additional collars (SDR-AXS).

Pros

• Designed for high-drive, more stubborn dogs that do not respond to lower levels of static stimulation
• 500 yards of range and can support training up to 3 dogs with the same remote with purchase of additional collars
• No look operation and more levels of stimulation allow for more customized training

Cons

• The collar strap may not fit dogs with neck sizes smaller than 5 inches or larger than 22 inches
• The collar may not be suitable for dogs weighing less than 8 pounds
• The collar may not be suitable for dogs with sensitive skin

We found that the SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer 425XS is a reliable and effective tool for training stubborn dogs. The 21 levels of static stimulation, as well as the option to train with vibration (buzz) and tone (beep), provide a range of training options. The remote is designed for ease-of-use and no look operation, which allows you to focus on your dog and not your equipment.

The collar is also waterproof and submersible to 25 feet using DryTek technology, which means you can use it in any weather condition. The rechargeable lithium-ion batteries last 50-70 hours per charge, and the system has low battery indicators.

Overall, we highly recommend the SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer 425XS for anyone looking for a reliable and effective training collar for their stubborn dog.

2. SportDOG Brand YardTrainer 100S

If you’re looking for a training collar that can handle stubborn dogs, the SportDOG Brand YardTrainer 100S is a great option. With its 100-yard range and three stimulation types, you’ll have the tools you need to train your pup in no time.

Pros

• The collar is designed for dogs that don’t respond to lower levels of static stimulation, making it a great choice for stubborn pups.
• You can choose to train with vibration, tone, or eight levels of static stimulation, giving you plenty of options to find what works best for your dog.
• The collar is waterproof and submersible to 25 feet using DryTek technology, so you can use it in any weather or water conditions.

Cons

• The collar only has a 100-yard range, which may not be enough for in-the-field training or hunting.
• The collar is designed for dogs that are 8 pounds or larger with neck sizes 5″ – 22″, so it may not be suitable for smaller dogs.
• The collar’s rechargeable lithium-ion batteries last 50-70 hours per charge, which may not be enough for longer training sessions or trips.

We’ve been using the SportDOG Brand YardTrainer 100S with our stubborn dog, and it has been a game-changer. The collar’s higher range of static stimulation has helped get our dog’s attention when other collars haven’t, and the option to train with vibration or tone has been a great way to mix up our training routine. Plus, the collar’s waterproof design means we can use it rain or shine.

One thing to keep in mind is that the collar’s 100-yard range may not be enough for larger training areas or hunting. Additionally, the rechargeable batteries may not last long enough for extended training sessions or trips. However, overall we highly recommend the SportDOG Brand YardTrainer 100S for anyone looking to train a stubborn dog.

3. DOG CARE Dog Training Collar with Remote

If you’re looking for an effective way to train your furry friend, the DOG CARE Dog Training Collar with Remote might be just what you need. With three safe and effective training modes, this collar can help you teach good behavior to your dogs.

Pros

• The DOG CARE dog training collar with remote offers three safe modes (beep, vibration, and shock) to educate your dogs.
• Compared with other devices, these shock collars for small dogs with remote are carefully designed with a security keypad that allows you to prevent any misfires, making the training work better.
• This dog training shock collar is also designed for easy operation, with an intuitive design that fits beautifully in the palm of your hand.

Cons

• The collar needs to be tight or it won’t work because it is a typical collar with electrodes that need to touch the dog.
• Any kind of hair on the dog makes the response a bit of hit and miss.
• It might not be suitable for all dogs, especially those with anxiety or aggression issues.

We’ve tried the DOG CARE Dog Training Collar with Remote on our own pets, and we found it to be an effective tool to train dogs. The collar is easy to use, and the remote control allows you to adjust the static level quickly. We also appreciate the fact that it’s rechargeable, which saves us money on batteries.

The collar is designed for pet owners, dog walkers, and professional trainers, and it can correct the annoying habits like barking, chewing, biting, and digging. It’s also suitable for dogs of different sizes, as the static level is reduced to 10, making it easier for the dog to feel the difference clearly.

Overall, we recommend the DOG CARE Dog Training Collar with Remote to anyone looking for an effective and safe way to train their dogs. However, we advise you to use it with caution and always follow the instructions carefully.

4. Dogtra 1900S Remote Training E-Collar

If you’re looking for a reliable and durable e-collar for your dog, the Dogtra 1900S Remote Training E-Collar is a great option. With a range of up to 3/4 mile, this collar is perfect for training your dog in any environment.

Pros

• The slim design receiver and collar are ergonomically shaped to fit your dog’s neck comfortably.
• The rheostat/volume dial allows for precise levels of stimulation, from 0-127.
• The collar receiver and transmitter are fully waterproof, making it suitable for use in all weather conditions.

Cons

• The collar should not be worn for more than 2 hours per day at first and 10 hours maximum after 4 to 8 weeks to prevent skin irritations from pressure from the contact points.
• The collar is not recommended for dogs younger than 4 months old.
• If your dog becomes aggressive during training, seek professional help.

We’ve found the Dogtra 1900S Remote Training E-Collar to be a reliable and effective tool for training our stubborn dog. The LCD screen displays the training levels and battery status, making it easy to keep track of the collar’s settings. The collar has three training modes: momentary, constant, and high power pager vibration only mode. We appreciate the versatility of this collar, as it has proven to be dependable for multiple types of dog training.

The collar’s precise stimulation control allows us to choose between 127 levels of low-high controlled stimulations that fit our dog’s personality. This dog training e-collar comes with nick (quick 1/2 second), constant (up to 12 seconds), and vibration corrections. We’ve found that the collar’s low to high power training levels are effective for training even the most sensitive of dogs.

The Dogtra 1900S Remote Training E-Collar is fully waterproof, making it durable and built to withstand the most demanding conditions like high heat or the cold winter season. The slim receiver design ensures the collar fits comfortably around your dog’s neck. The checkered grip on the transmitter provides non-slip operation on the go. This collar is ideal for dogs 35 pounds and up.

In conclusion, we highly recommend the Dogtra 1900S Remote Training E-Collar for anyone looking for a reliable and durable e-collar for their dog. With its long range, precise stimulation control, and versatile training modes, this collar is a great tool for training any dog with mild to most stubborn temperaments.

5. Petrainer Training Collar for Dogs

If you’re looking for a reliable training collar for your stubborn dog, the Petrainer Training Collar for Dogs is worth considering.

Pros

• The collar comes with three training modes, including static stimulation, vibration, and standard tone mode, so you can find the right correction for your dog’s behavior.
• The collar is waterproof, so you don’t have to worry about it getting damaged if your dog loves to swim or play in the rain.
• The remote range is up to 330 yards, giving you plenty of space to train your dog in different environments.

Cons

• Some customers have reported that the collar caused seizures in their dogs on the lowest shock setting, so it’s important to use caution and closely monitor your dog’s reaction to the collar.
• The instructions can be difficult to understand, so it may take some trial and error to figure out how to use the collar effectively.
• The collar is designed for dogs of all sizes, but some customers have reported that it may not fit well on very small dogs.

In our experience, the Petrainer Training Collar for Dogs is a good option for dogs that need extra training and correction. The waterproof design and remote range make it easy to use in a variety of settings, and the three training modes give you flexibility in how you correct your dog’s behavior. However, it’s important to use caution when using the collar and closely monitor your dog’s reaction to ensure their safety.

Overall, if you’re looking for a training collar that can help you put an end to bad behaviors like barking and leash pulling, the Petrainer Training Collar for Dogs is a solid choice.

6. Petrainer PET998DRB2 Dog Training Collar with Remote for 2 Dogs

If you’re looking for a versatile and effective dog training collar, the Petrainer PET998DRB2 is a great option. We’ve used it ourselves and have found it to be a reliable tool for training stubborn dogs.

Pros

• The collar is adjustable and fits small, medium, and large dogs.
• The collar is waterproof, making it ideal for use in all weather conditions.
• The remote has a range of up to 330 yards, giving you plenty of space to train your dog.

Cons

• The battery life could be better.
• The collar may not work for dogs with severe behavioral issues.
• The collar can be difficult to put on and take off.

We’ve found that the Petrainer PET998DRB2 is an effective training collar for most dogs. The three different modes (vibration, static, and standard tone) give you plenty of options for correcting your dog’s behavior. The collar is also adjustable, so it can be used on dogs of all sizes.

One of the best things about this collar is that it’s waterproof. This means that you don’t have to worry about taking it off when your dog goes for a swim or plays in the rain. The remote also has a long range, so you can train your dog from a distance.

However, the battery life could be better. If you’re planning on using the collar frequently, you’ll need to charge it often. Additionally, the collar may not be effective for dogs with severe behavioral issues. Finally, some users have found that the collar can be difficult to put on and take off.

Overall, we recommend the Petrainer PET998DRB2 for anyone looking for a versatile and effective training collar for their dog.

7. INVIROX Dog Shock Collar [Ultra K9]

If you’re looking for a reliable and effective dog training collar, the INVIROX Dog Shock Collar [Ultra K9] might be a great option for you. With a 4.7 rating and 26 total ratings, this collar has been tested and proven to be a safe and efficient tool for training your furry friend.

Pros

• The ergonomic remote and two ways to wear (belt clip and lanyard) make it easy to use and keep track of.
• The collar has 124 training levels, including beep, vibration, and shock modes, so you can find the right level for your dog’s needs.
• With a ¾ mile range, this collar is perfect for training large dogs or taking them on off-leash adventures.

Cons

• Some may find the price to be on the higher side compared to other training collars.
• While the keypad lock ensures no accidental shocks, there is still a potential for misuse if not used properly.
• The collar is only suitable for dogs weighing between 8 and 150 pounds, so it may not be the best option for very small or very large dogs.

Overall, we highly recommend the INVIROX Dog Shock Collar [Ultra K9] for anyone looking to train their dog in a safe and effective way. With 24/7 customer service and a 1-year warranty, you can trust that you’re making a solid investment in your dog’s training.

Buying Guide

When it comes to buying a training collar for your stubborn dog, there are a few things to keep in mind to ensure you choose the best product for your needs. In this section, we will outline the key features to look for when shopping for a training collar.

Type of Collar

There are several types of training collars available, including:

• Shock Collars: These collars use a mild electric shock to get your dog’s attention and discourage unwanted behavior.
• Vibration Collars: These collars vibrate to get your dog’s attention and can be a good alternative to shock collars for more sensitive dogs.
• Spray Collars: These collars spray a burst of citronella or other unpleasant scents to discourage unwanted behavior.

Consider which type of collar will work best for your dog’s temperament and the behaviors you are trying to correct.

Range and Sensitivity

The range and sensitivity of the collar are important factors to consider, especially if you plan on using the collar for off-leash training. Look for collars with a range that matches the distance you need to communicate with your dog and adjustable sensitivity levels to ensure the collar responds appropriately to your dog’s behavior.

Durability and Comfort

Choose a collar that is durable enough to withstand your dog’s activity level and comfortable enough for them to wear for extended periods. Look for collars made from high-quality materials and with adjustable sizing to ensure a proper fit.

Additional Features

Some training collars come with additional features, such as remote control, rechargeable batteries, and waterproofing. Consider which features are important to you and your training needs.

By keeping these factors in mind, you can choose the best training collar for your stubborn dog and improve their behavior in a safe and effective way.

Frequently Asked Questions

What features should I look for in a training collar for a small yet stubborn dog?

When choosing a training collar for a small yet stubborn dog, it’s important to look for a collar that is adjustable, lightweight, and has a range of stimulation levels. A collar with a small receiver is also recommended, as it will be more comfortable for your dog to wear.

How can I ensure the training collar is humane for my dog while still being effective?

To ensure that the training collar is humane for your dog, it’s important to choose a collar that has adjustable stimulation levels and to start with the lowest level of stimulation. It’s also important to use positive reinforcement in conjunction with the collar to encourage good behavior.

What are the best-rated training collars for multi-dog households?

When it comes to training collars for multi-dog households, it’s important to choose a collar that has a range of stimulation levels and can be used on multiple dogs. Some of the best-rated training collars for multi-dog households include the SportDOG FieldTrainer 425X, the Garmin Delta XC, and the Educator E-Collar Mini.

Can aggressive dogs be effectively trained with a shock collar, and what are the safety considerations?

While shock collars can be effective for training aggressive dogs, it’s important to use them with caution and to choose a collar that has adjustable stimulation levels. It’s also important to use positive reinforcement in conjunction with the collar and to avoid using the collar as a punishment.

What are the advantages of using a training collar with a remote for behavior modification?

Using a training collar with a remote allows you to train your dog from a distance, which can be particularly useful for behavior modification. It also allows you to adjust the stimulation level of the collar as needed and to provide immediate feedback to your dog.

How do different types of training collars compare in terms of training stubborn dogs?

Different types of training collars, such as shock collars, vibration collars, and spray collars, can be effective for training stubborn dogs. However, it’s important to choose a collar that is appropriate for your dog’s temperament and to use the collar in conjunction with positive reinforcement.